This has nothing to do with Christianity, and everything to do with public displays of grandeur.
I mean, great - he found a thing (the Jesus) that frees him from his addictions. Good for him. Now shut up about it.
That's why this is appropriate to north Texas. Because the myth of Texas is that loudness in all things - even the humility of Christ - should be celebrated.
This is an incredibly poorly thought-through article. As an atheist, I don't really have an issue with you taking shots an Christianity, even though your sneering, fifth-grade tone is embarrassing. But your suggestion that Hamilton is delighted that he relapsed, that he really enjoyed that night shows such a lack of understanding about the nature of alcoholism that...honestly, you should be ashamed of yourself. The thing is, I'm sure Hamilton was relieved that night in Tempe. I'm sure he was really happy. When he gets up in the morning, he wants to drink. When he goes to bed, or goes to church, he wants to drink. He got something that he desperately wants, 24/7, but couldn't have. If he could somehow have it both ways, he would drink all the time, because he is totally addicted and will never, ever shake that addiction. If he hadn't used his love for the game (and his love for Christ) to turn his life around, he would drink nonstop. He WAS unleashed - he had unleashed his inner demons. Suggesting that he found it to be a happy reprieve is juvenile and ignorant.
@MeanMachine: Context context context. She's suggesting that he was secretly doing fist-pumps, that Sober Hamilton was glad to be drunk, while I'm suggesting that it was Drunk Hamilton who was happy.
@dan_in_accounting: When an alcoholic takes a drink, it's like he (or she, as the case may be) is another person. Loving father? Devoted husband? It all gets tossed out the window the second you take a drink. It's like an entirely different personality has been swapped into the same body.
"He looks happy" well no shit, he's drunk off his ass. Its whether you can be happy the next morning that determines if you're an alcoholic or not, and clearly he had some 'splainin to do when he woke up.
@Chris Hanson's Axe: I took the implication to be that he was happy to be doing what he spends the majority of his life now fighting the urge to do. In that case I think it would be a relief and don't think its wrong to suggest it.
as for the other stuff, alcoholism, it seems, is a much more subjective disease than others and for someone who is not an alcoholic to speak about what happens to an alcoholic when they drink is speaking from a misguided position of authority.
@dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac: Well Senor Crash's assertion that its an instantaneous, Popeye-eating-spinach-like transition between wholesome Christian and godless hellraiser with only one drop of alcohol for EVERY alcoholic seemed heavy-handed, but I don't think its too far out of line to suggest that maybe Josh Hamilton, and maybe just Josh Hamilton, fits that description. There is some proof of this out there.
And I get your point... but yeah... He's drunk. Drinking makes you happy momentarily, sure, but I'm sure there's other pictures of him smiling, too, without the booze's assistance.
@MisterCrash: OK, not disagreeing with your interpretation (Jekylton/Hamilhyde, Sober Hamilton regrets his actions, walking a tightrope), but I just think you're parsing it a bit too finely. I took the main point as: for Hamilton, his particular brand of struggle/redemption will be well understood and supported in his community, given the prevailing Christian culture. As an atheist I don't buy the concept of "I am weak without the Lord" but I have little concern with people using their religion to help themselves fix legitimate problems within their own lives. I just don't want to hear it preached so loudly and resolutely. I suspect, as did the post, that this redemption song would be less well received in a place less wrapped up Hamilton's particular religious belief system.
@dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac: I'm sure Drunk Hamilton was relieved. Drunk Hamilton has wanted to drink for four years and was only just then getting the chance. But do you think Sober Hamilton was relieved to betray what he views as a sacred commitment to God and his family? That he was relieved to risk his career and marriage for the sake of one night of drinking?
@Chris Hanson's Axe: I should clarify. The "thrown out the window with one drop" refers primarily reformed alcoholics who are relapsing. I agree that not every alcoholic is like that, especially alcoholics who are making no attempt to kick the habit.
@MisterCrash: This is why I asked if you were an alcoholic. Since I am not, I don't think anyway, I dont feel 100% comfortable saying you are totally off base with your split personality view of alcoholics. But that's how I see it. There is no drunk Josh Hamilton and Sober Josh Hamilton. There is only Josh Hamilton, who every moment of his life (apparently) has to fight the urge to drink alcohol. I would imagine a recovering alcoholic felt normal while drinking and abnormal while not drinking but learned at some point that that is not a healthy way to go through life.
So, I think it is fair to say that when Hamilton got hammered, it was a relief because he could stop fighting and do what his mind or body or whatever had been dying to do for so long. He could stop pretending to be something he is not. Sure, he probably regretted it the next day, because he knows he cant allow himself to do that anymore, but that doesn't change the fact that he was relieved and enjoying himself.
@dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac: I feel like you and I are reaching the point where we're fighting over semantics and splitting hairs. I understand but respectfully disagree with your position. However, what I really took umbrage with:
"a truth that seems pretty apparent upon glancing at those bar photos: Josh Hamilton looks really happy in those pictures. He looks like a man whose life for the past five years has been, as he once put it, "Park. Home. Park. Home," a man who has been living day after day within arms' reach of his 60-something babysitter, and a man who, for a few hours, finally has some room to explode. Hamilton looks like a man unleashed."
The author's suggestion that Hamilton was actually going "Phew! Boy, I sure am glad I'm getting to break my commitment to God and risk my career and marriage in the name of one night of drinking! Ha ha, these crazy Christians, am I right?!" is just totally ignorant. If that's not what the author was going for, well, then she's just a shitty writer and the editors should have told her as much as they threw her submitted column in the trash.
@MisterCrash: Thats what I'm saying: that is not the implication I got at all. First of all, religion is not mentioned in your quote. Secondly I dont see the "im happy to be jeopardizing my career" angle either. Hamilton's religious conversion is the reason he's alive, and it's the reason he was able to man up and come clean to his wife and to the media about his giant slip-up. Say what you will about the relentless Bible-thumping, but if you listen to Hamilton's press conference on Saturday, you can't say he's not honest, or accountable, or remorseful, or embarrassed.
I dont know how you interpret that as sneering.
The article reads to me like "since cleaning up, he has been fighting himself every minute of every day and finally one day dropped his guard and was able to be free." I dont think there is anything sneering about that. I think its the truth.
Think about people on a diet. They deprive themselves of things they love and if they break, they probably enjoy it, but also feel guilty afterwards. Thats all. In the end, you are going to read into it what you read into it. You're obviously a huge fan of his and are sticking up for him. Thats fine, but of all the hatchet jobs out there to pick on, this one is not "poorly thought out" or whatever other unnecessary adverbs you used.
08/31/09
08/31/09
The seats were then given supplemental picks in next years draft.
08/31/09
08/31/09
08/14/09
Give it a fucking break already, Linda Cohn.
08/14/09
I mean, great - he found a thing (the Jesus) that frees him from his addictions. Good for him. Now shut up about it.
That's why this is appropriate to north Texas. Because the myth of Texas is that loudness in all things - even the humility of Christ - should be celebrated.
08/14/09
Jewish people know why Christians love capital letters. It springs from their love of capital punishment.
08/14/09
08/14/09
Because they are terrified of lower-case Ts.
08/14/09
"t," as in "time to leave?"
08/14/09
08/14/09
08/14/09
Then, Suggesting that he found it to be a happy reprieve is juvenile and ignorant.
Well make up your mind dude. Is he gonna shit or is he gonna kill us?
08/14/09
@dan_in_accounting: When an alcoholic takes a drink, it's like he (or she, as the case may be) is another person. Loving father? Devoted husband? It all gets tossed out the window the second you take a drink. It's like an entirely different personality has been swapped into the same body.
08/14/09
08/14/09
"He looks happy" well no shit, he's drunk off his ass. Its whether you can be happy the next morning that determines if you're an alcoholic or not, and clearly he had some 'splainin to do when he woke up.
08/14/09
as for the other stuff, alcoholism, it seems, is a much more subjective disease than others and for someone who is not an alcoholic to speak about what happens to an alcoholic when they drink is speaking from a misguided position of authority.
08/14/09
And I get your point... but yeah... He's drunk. Drinking makes you happy momentarily, sure, but I'm sure there's other pictures of him smiling, too, without the booze's assistance.
08/14/09
08/14/09
@Chris Hanson's Axe: I should clarify. The "thrown out the window with one drop" refers primarily reformed alcoholics who are relapsing. I agree that not every alcoholic is like that, especially alcoholics who are making no attempt to kick the habit.
08/14/09
So, I think it is fair to say that when Hamilton got hammered, it was a relief because he could stop fighting and do what his mind or body or whatever had been dying to do for so long. He could stop pretending to be something he is not. Sure, he probably regretted it the next day, because he knows he cant allow himself to do that anymore, but that doesn't change the fact that he was relieved and enjoying himself.
08/15/09
"a truth that seems pretty apparent upon glancing at those bar photos: Josh Hamilton looks really happy in those pictures. He looks like a man whose life for the past five years has been, as he once put it, "Park. Home. Park. Home," a man who has been living day after day within arms' reach of his 60-something babysitter, and a man who, for a few hours, finally has some room to explode. Hamilton looks like a man unleashed."
The author's suggestion that Hamilton was actually going "Phew! Boy, I sure am glad I'm getting to break my commitment to God and risk my career and marriage in the name of one night of drinking! Ha ha, these crazy Christians, am I right?!" is just totally ignorant. If that's not what the author was going for, well, then she's just a shitty writer and the editors should have told her as much as they threw her submitted column in the trash.
08/17/09
Hamilton's religious conversion is the reason he's alive, and it's the reason he was able to man up and come clean to his wife and to the media about his giant slip-up. Say what you will about the relentless Bible-thumping, but if you listen to Hamilton's press conference on Saturday, you can't say he's not honest, or accountable, or remorseful, or embarrassed.
I dont know how you interpret that as sneering.
The article reads to me like "since cleaning up, he has been fighting himself every minute of every day and finally one day dropped his guard and was able to be free." I dont think there is anything sneering about that. I think its the truth.
Think about people on a diet. They deprive themselves of things they love and if they break, they probably enjoy it, but also feel guilty afterwards. Thats all. In the end, you are going to read into it what you read into it. You're obviously a huge fan of his and are sticking up for him. Thats fine, but of all the hatchet jobs out there to pick on, this one is not "poorly thought out" or whatever other unnecessary adverbs you used.
08/14/09
08/14/09
Yeah - for health care reform!
/topical
08/14/09
Which, coincidentally, is what Al Sharpton calls the Puerto Rican part of Queens.
08/14/09
Ann Darrow.
08/14/09
08/14/09
08/14/09