The Gayest (And Straightest) Super Bowl Halftime Shows 1Tom Scocca and 5 others eEditaDeleteBPromoteXDismissXUndismissbBlock for sitebHide How shocking would it be if Madonna brought gay themes to the Super Bowl halftime show? Not very. Throughout its history, the halftime entertainment has meandered from straight to gay and back again. (Click here for my homemade infographic rating the halftime shows from straightest to gayest.) » 1/30/12 5:25pm 1/30/12 5:25pmHomemade Infographic: What Were The Gayest (And Straightest) Super Bowl Halftime Shows?