Those are cool, interesting, revealing stats, but it's awfully convenient to post them right after A-Rod has a MONSTER 3-game set against the lowly Twins. Factor out those at-bats and it's easy to see why A-Rod has understandably HAD a reputation as an awful postseason hitter. Moreover, factor out A-Rod's postseason at-bats from before he was a Yankee, and you'll see that as a YANKEE postseason hitter he still pales in comparison with Reggie. In other words, A-Rod JUST FINALLY had his first good spell in the postseason as a Yankee, and before now most of the positive postseason numbers he ever put up happened when he was in Seattle (where his postseason average was like .340). Also, don't forget that Reggie did most of his damage in more meaningful games (ALCS's and WS's). Just sayin'. Still, very interesting stat. It'll be interesting to see if A-Rod's batting average implodes the deeper into October he goes.
Stochasticity indicates that more often than not, the moment we believe a certain athlete to be at his 'hottest', he is, in fact, statistically ice cold. Sports fans in particular have a penchant for cherry-picking certain stats while disregarding or ignoring the underlying the probabilities.
Sorry, but there's really no such thing as "clutch" or "red-hotness" in sports. It's just us trying to put random events in an order that matches our desired conclusions.
Also, yes, A-Rod is a huge douche. Reggie less so. And there's nothing random about that.
@bmoreDLJ: Disagree. Dimaggio's 56-game hit streak is a prime example of "red-hotness," striking even from a drab, statistical standpoint.
I'd also argue there IS such thing as "clutch." Yeah, guys that are clutch will of course miss shots at the end of games, strike-out, what have you. But you can't deny some players are at their best in end of game situations (Jordan) while others are noticably worse (Webber, Malone) or that hitters have streaks and slumps. Over time, sure, it evens out, but those stretches are a reality as well.
@AC_Greens_Virginity: Logical fallacy. Jordan was exemplary in every part of his game from minute one until the end. To pick out a handful of situations at the end of a game and conclude that he was somehow "better" towards the end of games when the outcome was still in doubt completely ignores the fact that he was just as good for the other 46 minutes a game. Most players who people deem to be "clutch" are usually, statistically speaking, just as competent at all other times.
@Hit Bull Win Steak: Those are fair points. I submit, for your approval, Robert Horry, in no way exemplary in every part of his game but who had a penchant for the big moment. He's definitely deemed "clutch," but, statistically speaking, is nowhere near Jordan's league. Hell, he's a mid-tier talent at best, yet I specifically remember four or five moments where he just buried teams at the end of the game.
Anecdotal? Yeah, admittedly, a bit. But that's what those "clutch" moments are: anecdotal. They don't come around that often. And when a guy pulls a Big Shot Bob or a Kirk Gibson gimping homerun, it's so memorable that it's hard to not think of them as clutch. So it's a shot that Horry usually makes? Great. Point is he made it at the exact moment he needed to to win a game, at a moment with an absurd amount of added pressure. It's not "just another three pointer."
10/13/09
10/12/09
10/13/09
10/12/09
10/12/09
10/12/09
10/12/09
10/12/09
Sorry, but there's really no such thing as "clutch" or "red-hotness" in sports. It's just us trying to put random events in an order that matches our desired conclusions.
Also, yes, A-Rod is a huge douche. Reggie less so. And there's nothing random about that.
10/12/09
Also, I think Craggs' tone may have eluded you.
10/12/09
I'd also argue there IS such thing as "clutch." Yeah, guys that are clutch will of course miss shots at the end of games, strike-out, what have you. But you can't deny some players are at their best in end of game situations (Jordan) while others are noticably worse (Webber, Malone) or that hitters have streaks and slumps. Over time, sure, it evens out, but those stretches are a reality as well.
10/12/09
10/12/09
Anecdotal? Yeah, admittedly, a bit. But that's what those "clutch" moments are: anecdotal. They don't come around that often. And when a guy pulls a Big Shot Bob or a Kirk Gibson gimping homerun, it's so memorable that it's hard to not think of them as clutch. So it's a shot that Horry usually makes? Great. Point is he made it at the exact moment he needed to to win a game, at a moment with an absurd amount of added pressure. It's not "just another three pointer."
10/12/09
06/19/09
/bitter Oilers fan
06/19/09
So can Dmitri Khristich.
/as a Leaf: 80 games, 15 goals, 39 points, $5 million.
06/19/09
Hw dd Brdy Qnn gt nvlvd n ll f ths?
06/19/09
LAME, HACK JOKE ERROR.
GET YOUR SHIT TOGETHER, WINGNUT.
06/19/09
You forgot about the "CZ Bandit".
06/19/09
06/19/09
06/19/09
In other words, Joe wore the lampshade.
06/19/09
He was too busy catching Grover Cleveland Alexander's 45th no-hitter.
06/19/09
/hat tip
06/19/09
06/19/09
Shocking.
06/19/09
06/19/09