Wait, so they want someone who couldn't hit anything except a home run (and that was only due to performance enhancing drugs) to be the Cardinals hitting coach? As a Cubs fan, I'm all for this. #markmcgwire
I don't know about "hitching" my wagon, but I am gonna paint our wagon, gonna paint it fine, gonna use an oil based paint, cause this wood is pine. #markmcgwire
Who cares about his reputation? When a guy with a .263 lifetime average and 100 strikeouts a year asks to be your hitting coach you say yes. #markmcgwire
@Convict78: Whats the correlation of guys who are not good at hitting baseballs in the majors ever becoming good at it based on what some guy said? #markmcgwire
@Moobs: Charley Lau, widely regarded as one of the greatest hitting coaches of all time, had a lifetime BA of .255. Walt Hriniak had 25 career hits, and spent 20 years in the Bigs as a highly respected hitting coach. I could rattle off the names of other mediocre, at best, players who went on to become very successful hitting/pitching coaches, but I won't, because it's a futile gesture. Other than maybe Rod Carew, name me the last great hitter that was successful as a hitting coach. #markmcgwire
@metalmaniac: Maybe the good coaches had good hitters and the bad coaches had bad hitters?
Other than trying to install a philosophy, i.e. take pitches, work the count, I fail to see how a "hitting coach" can have any discernible impact on a major leaguer's ability to hit a baseball effectively. #markmcgwire
@dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese... mac: Have you never read stories of players who credit their coaches with noticing something wrong in their mechanics? Do you really assume that all players come to the majors fully-formed, and that coaching is not helpful?
Ways coaches help players:
1) Installing a philosophy, i.e. take pitches, work the count (thanks for providing the first example that undermines your argument)
2) Correct hitches or poor mechanics in players' swings or pitching motions
3) Teach new skills (many coaches have taught pitchers how to throw different pitches)
4) Suggest new batting stances and take the time to help players learn and get used to them
5) Watch film for clues about opponents and share that knowledge (when Santana holds his glove this way, a changeup is coming, etc.)
@ohmygodtheykilledkennyrogers: If a guy can hit a baseball, he can hit a fucking baseball. As much as players always credit their hitting coach, (which now that you mention it I have read those articles and they totally validate your argument), Im pretty sure A-rod was good at hitting before he met Kevin Long. The minor adjustments you mention, are just that. Sure, they are luxury you can afford to have when you are raking in money, but they are by no means necessary to the game and the players ability to play it.
@Dashiell Bennett: He's not Tiger Woods because of his swing coach, though. Golf is also much different than baseball. I don't know much about it, but there are tons of different types of shots to make, each with a different type of swing. I can see how a coach would be more beneficial.
Edited by dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac at 10/26/09 2:12 PM
dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac was starred
dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac was unstarred
@Spielman: If you're not a good hitter by the time you get to the Major Leagues, chances are you are just not a good hitter. But by all means, keep hoping you find that magical person who will unlock the mysteries of being able to hit like a champion because he saw tape of you and thinks you should just have a little bit higher of a leg kick. #markmcgwire
@dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese... mac: Good point. The key to a long, productive career is the if it aint broke... mentality. Leave the adjustments and need for improvement for those over-achievers.
Do you by chance, work in the Royals front office? #markmcgwire
@Jobu's Refill: Are you trying to say that great baseball hitters are reliant on "good" "hitting coaches" and specifically minor adjustments made over the course of a season? We can save ourselves a lot of aggravation if you are.
Edited by dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac at 10/26/09 2:54 PM
dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac was starred
dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac was unstarred
@dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese... mac: I think you're really missing the difference between: 1) turning a crappy hitter into a great one and
2) helping any hitter improve, even slightly, over the course of a season or career.
You are referring to #1. Everybody else is referring to #2.
I would also argue that hitting and pitching coaches are not a "luxury," as they have been pretty standard throughout baseball (majors, minors, and college) for decades. #markmcgwire
@dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese...... mac: I'm saying great hitters, and more specifically great swings are not produced over-night. That they are constantly studied/evaluated/adjusted.I'm saying the exact job description of a hitting coach is to assist players in that study/evaluation/adjustment. So yes, a good hitting coach can be a huge help to even great hitters. Even the great swings have holes. And even the great hitters can slip into flaws. Pitchers will find them. Hitters and hitting coaches work to stay ahead of that curve.Not even mentioning the preperation that hitters and coaches utilize going into each at bat. #markmcgwire
/dick joke
@ohmygodtheykilledkennyrogers: Since I'm the one you are all responding to, maybe I am not missing any point, and in fact, continuing to make the same point I originally made and you are all taking about the wrong thing.
Like I said, are you saying a "good" "hitting coach" is responsible for quality major league hitting? I think you'd be foolish to argue that. Can he help a guy out? Sure. Its always good to have a second set of eyes looking over your work. But, if you can't write, all the editors in the world can't turn you into a great writer. That was, and continues to be, my point. So, please, don't tell me what I'm missing the point on.
My point about it being a luxury is, like I said in black and white, its not necessary but since there's no shortage of money and everyone else has one, why not have him. A hitting coach is not integral to the game of baseball. i.e. a luxury.
No one is talking about pitching coaches.
Thanks for letting me know that hitting and pitching coaches are "pretty standard" throughout baseball, though. #markmcgwire
@Jobu's Refill: again: great hitters are great because of hitting coaches, or are hitting coaches just helpful? Maybe a hitting coach gets a guy out of a slump quicker because he "picks up on something in his swing" I dont know. Maybe. The guy still has to be able to hit a baseball well.
I refuse to believe, however, that a hitting coach is actually worth all the attention he gets. And no hitting coach is turning an average minor league hitter into an above average major league hitter. So, what are we even talking about? #markmcgwire
@dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese... mac: A good hitting coach on the field, or in the front office identifies the players and swings that can or cannot make good major league hitters.
Hence the Royals reference. We were promised the second coming of George Brett in Alex Gordon. Except that everyone else in the league recognized the gaping holes in his swing. The things over-looked by the organization and his minor-league hitting instructor, the first coming of George Brett. #markmcgwire
@Spielman: Hey look! The only guy to not make any kind of point, in a thread with, like, 20 comments and legitimate points being made on either side, just called me dumb!
Everyone Else: here are reasons why I think hitting coaches are valuable/overrated.
You: You are a douche. You are dumb.
I think we can stop this now, don't you? #markmcgwire
Hey America, maybe we move past this steriod thing, and maybe my enormous son doesn't come by and smash your home into a million-billion tiny little pieces-- your choice. #markmcgwire
10/26/09
He's getting sloppy seconds on Brad Penny, Carl Pavano, Barry Zito and Russell Martin? #tonylarussa
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
You're right. These first few could be the setup to make it look legit. #tonylarussa
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/27/09
Real Ron Artest? Birdman Andersen? I thought you were those too. #tonylarussa
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
/Except that there's not #markmcgwire
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
Other than trying to install a philosophy, i.e. take pitches, work the count, I fail to see how a "hitting coach" can have any discernible impact on a major leaguer's ability to hit a baseball effectively. #markmcgwire
10/26/09
10/26/09
Ways coaches help players:
1) Installing a philosophy, i.e. take pitches, work the count (thanks for providing the first example that undermines your argument)
2) Correct hitches or poor mechanics in players' swings or pitching motions
3) Teach new skills (many coaches have taught pitchers how to throw different pitches)
4) Suggest new batting stances and take the time to help players learn and get used to them
5) Watch film for clues about opponents and share that knowledge (when Santana holds his glove this way, a changeup is coming, etc.)
I'm sure there are hundreds more. #markmcgwire
10/26/09
@Dashiell Bennett: He's not Tiger Woods because of his swing coach, though. Golf is also much different than baseball. I don't know much about it, but there are tons of different types of shots to make, each with a different type of swing. I can see how a coach would be more beneficial.
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
Do you by chance, work in the Royals front office? #markmcgwire
10/26/09
10/26/09
2) helping any hitter improve, even slightly, over the course of a season or career.
You are referring to #1. Everybody else is referring to #2.
I would also argue that hitting and pitching coaches are not a "luxury," as they have been pretty standard throughout baseball (majors, minors, and college) for decades. #markmcgwire
10/26/09
/dick joke
10/26/09
Like I said, are you saying a "good" "hitting coach" is responsible for quality major league hitting? I think you'd be foolish to argue that. Can he help a guy out? Sure. Its always good to have a second set of eyes looking over your work. But, if you can't write, all the editors in the world can't turn you into a great writer. That was, and continues to be, my point. So, please, don't tell me what I'm missing the point on.
My point about it being a luxury is, like I said in black and white, its not necessary but since there's no shortage of money and everyone else has one, why not have him. A hitting coach is not integral to the game of baseball. i.e. a luxury.
No one is talking about pitching coaches.
Thanks for letting me know that hitting and pitching coaches are "pretty standard" throughout baseball, though. #markmcgwire
10/26/09
I refuse to believe, however, that a hitting coach is actually worth all the attention he gets. And no hitting coach is turning an average minor league hitter into an above average major league hitter. So, what are we even talking about? #markmcgwire
10/26/09
Hence the Royals reference. We were promised the second coming of George Brett in Alex Gordon. Except that everyone else in the league recognized the gaping holes in his swing. The things over-looked by the organization and his minor-league hitting instructor, the first coming of George Brett. #markmcgwire
10/26/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/28/09
Everyone Else: here are reasons why I think hitting coaches are valuable/overrated.
You: You are a douche. You are dumb.
I think we can stop this now, don't you? #markmcgwire
10/28/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
No way, Jose. I just bought this wagon last week! #markmcgwire
10/26/09
- Bob Griese #markmcgwire
10/26/09
"Swing through the fucking pitch! Through the pitch!! ARGH!!!!!!" #markmcgwire
10/26/09
I'm not so sure about that last one. Has he given Al Davis a call yet? #markmcgwire
10/26/09
10/26/09
If I Did It...the Mark McGwire Steroid Story? #markmcgwire