Photo via AP/Frank Franklin II

A Florida judge today denied ESPN’s request to dismiss an invasion of privacy lawsuit that was brought against them by Giants defensive end Jason Pierre-Paul last February. Today’s ruling brings the suit that much closer to trial, and according to Pro Football Talk, the trial is scheduled to begin next August.

Pierre-Paul is suing ESPN and NFL reporter Adam Schefter for publishing a picture of his medical records last summer.

Advertisement

Advertisement

ESPN’s lawyers argued before the judge that the case should be dismissed due to First Amendment protections. ESPN’s argument is that Pierre-Paul’s finger amputation—which occurred after he blew up his own hand in a fireworks mishap—was a matter of legitimate public concern given that Pierre-Paul is a famous athlete.

Pierre-Paul’s lawyers do not dispute that their client is a public figure and that Schefter had a right to report news about his accident, but they maintain that it was unnecessary for Schefter to tweet out an image of the records themselves, and that doing so was a violation of Pierre-Paul’s privacy.