Trevor Plouffe made a damn good play here, at least initially. He dived to his left to stop Juan Lagares's sharply hit grounder, then ... nothing. Plouffe's glove refused to give him the ball.
The replay at the 17-second mark shows Plouffe's reaction at the moment he expects the ball to roll out of his glove, like it's no doubt done for him thousands of times. But it was stuck in the webbing. Lagares was awarded a single. He would later score on a single by Eric Young.