Here's What A 1943 NFL Tryout Invitation Looked Like
Reddit user "drepicgames" posted a letter belonging to his great-uncle Harold "Butch" Gutke. Dated April 30, 1943, it invites Gutke to come try out for "the New York Football Giants."
It's signed by John V. "Jack" Mara, son of founder Tim Mara and uncle of current CEO John Mara. It offered Gutke, then a quarterback at Utah State, a $150 per game paycheck if he made the team, but he'd have to provide his own shoes. (I have no doubt the NFL would still have both those rules in effect if not for unionization.)
The letter makes reference to "being called for the colors"—in the early 40s, the nascent NFL was decimated by losing players to the war. (1943 was the year the Eagles and Steelers were merged because neither team had enough players to field a full roster.)
That's what happened to Butch Gutke, too. According to his 1999 obituary, he never tried out for the Giants, instead being drafted by the Navy.
[ Reddit]
Way Too Early 2026 NFL Head Coaching Cycle Predictions
Senators vs. Rangers Wednesday January 14th Betting Pick
Zac Taylor Somehow Survived Insane AFC North Shake Up
How John Harbaugh Froze the 2026 NFL Coaching Carousel
- NBA Best Bets Monday: Jazz vs Cavaliers, Lakers vs Kings, Hornets vs Clippers
- Texans vs Steelers Wild Card Pick: Top Monday Night Football Playoff Predictions
- NBA Picks and Predictions for January 11th: Best Bets for Sunday
- NFL Playoff Sunday January 11th Picks: Top Wild Card Bets
- College Basketball Picks Today: Saturday January 10th Best Bets
- Green Bay Packers vs. Chicago Bears NFL Playoffs Wild Card Betting Picks
- Washington Capitals vs. Chicago Blackhawks Betting Pick January 9th

