Plaxico Burress Is History's Greatest Monster Because He Stole A Punter's Number
It's standard operating procedure for newly acquired players to get their favored jersey number, but only after compensating the owner. It's been five years, and Burress still owes Jeff Feagles a new kitchen.
When Burress arrived with the Giants in 2005, he wanted No. 17. Problem is Feagles had that number, and it was special to him. He had given up his lifelong No. 10 to Eli Manning the year before, in exchange for a weeklong trip to Florida. So he had switched to 17, for his 17th year in the league.
So he cut a deal with Burress (or rather his agent, Drew Rosenhaus). No. 17, for a remodeled kitchen. Burress never paid up.
I never got paid for it," Feagles said. "I asked [Burress] for it. Every time I went to Drew he said, 'That's between you and Plax.' Bottom line, I never got paid. He basically stole my number."
The worst part is that Burress didn't want No. 17 for some super sentimental reason. He wanted it because he signed his deal with the Giants on March. 17.
Feagles is retired now, although the Giants offered him the "tarnished" number back. And Burress, of course, is wearing a much longer number.
Giants' Feagles says Burress stiffed him on jersey payment [SI]
2026 NFL Mock Draft: First 12 Picks Predictions and Analysis
March Madness Sunday Bets: Texas Tech, Tennessee
- Best March Madness Saturday Picks: Arkansas vs. High Point, Vanderbilt ML
- Akron vs Texas Tech, Clemson vs Iowa: Best Bets for Friday
- NCAA Tournament Thursday Picks: Why Georgia and Saint Mary’s Offer Value
- NBA Picks Today: Best Bets for Warriors vs Celtics, Lakers vs Rockets
- Miami (OH) vs SMU Prediction: Best Bet for NCAA Play-In Game
- MLB Home Run Leader Future Picks: Best Bets for 2026 Season
- Top NBA Picks for Today: Thunder vs Magic, Cavs vs Bucks, Nuggets vs 76ers

