Sports News Without Access, Favor, Or Discretion

Judge Throws Out Video Evidence In Robert Kraft's Solicitation Case

Photo: Scott Eisen (Getty)

The Palm Beach County judge overseeing Robert Kraft’s criminal case has said that certain pieces of evidence can be tossed. County Judge Leonard Hanser wrote in his ruling today that video—which police said showed Kraft receiving sex acts he later paid for at the Orchids of Asia Day Spa—can be suppressed because the warrant that allowed the recording did not have enough rules in place to protect innocent spa customers. Hanser also ruled that evidence gathered from a subsequent traffic stop of the car in which the New England Patriots owner was a passenger also can be tossed.

Kraft was charged earlier this year with two counts of misdemeanor solicitation of prostitution by police in Jupiter, Florida. He has pleaded not guilty to the charges.

Advertisement

Ultimately, Hanser sided with the arguments presented by Kraft’s defense lawyers. First, Hanser agreed that Kraft has a “reasonable, subjective expectation of privacy” inside a massage room. The judge then drilled down on the many ways he believed the search warrant, which was approved by a different judge, failed to outline proper steps for minimizing recording. The warrant did not talk about how to minimize surveillance of women clients, who were not suspected of paying for sex acts, nor did it talk about how to minimize recording of men who just got massages, he wrote. Hanser also said that the minimization steps put in place by police were not enough, noting that “the detective-monitors were simply left to their own standards and devices to satisfy the minimization requirement.”

Advertisement

Ultimately, the minimization techniques used “did not satisfy constitutional requirements,” Hanser wrote. The ruling also tossed evidence gathered during the subsequent police stop of Kraft’s car. The explanation for that decision is much briefer:

Advertisement

The ruling in full is below.

Share This Story

About the author

Diana Moskovitz

Senior editor at Deadspin

EmailTwitterPosts
PGP Fingerprint: FF57 38CF BB4A 84D1 834A 3BA2 D704 1D9F 659A B991PGP Key
OTR Fingerprint: AEEB7418 00D6AEA9 112206FF 3E97529D CE8C29C9