Silence is not good news. If Shazier was doing well, or on a path to full recovery, the Steelers and the NFL would make sure everyone knew, and we’d see more of him than just his silent appearance up in a Pittsburgh suite. This mystery makes no sense if Shazier’s injury was a standard “placed on injured reserve” affair.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Normally, this isn’t something that the general public is entitled to know. Shazier’s recovery should be a private journey between him and his loved ones, and, even as an NFL player, his medical information isn’t for everyone to analyze. But the Steelers pushing this “inspirational” moment of a seated Shazier getting cheered at his home stadium—while remaining tight-lipped about any potentially depressing details—raises a lot of questions that the NFL, itself, isn’t answering. And it shines a bright light on just how hard it is for the NFL to talk about the damage its game can do to players without a narrative of recovery or triumph over adversity.