Sports News Without Fear, Favor or Compromise
Sports News Without Fear, Favor or Compromise

Goal-Line Tech Expert: How FIFA Can Kick Bad Calls In 3 Easy Steps

Illustration for article titled Goal-Line Tech Expert: How FIFA Can Kick Bad Calls In 3 Easy Steps

Chuck Salter over at Fast Company is just like you: sick and tired of all the bad calls from refs during the World Cup. This is his three-point plan for FIFA to significantly reduce the number of shitty calls per game.


Sepp Blatter, FIFA's stubbornly immovable president, has long resisted in-game technology to assist soccer referees. But after two more blown calls on Sunday threatened to overshadow the World Cup, he inched toward acknowledging what a worldwide audience could see for themselves: Soccer is ready for the 21st century.

England's Frank Lampard was robbed of an obvious goal by out-of-position officials in a loss to Germany. And Argentina's Carlos Tevez scored an off-sides (read: illegal) goal that was allowed in a win over Mexico. Blatter apologized to the English and Mexican teams. "It would be nonsense not to reopen the file on goal-line technology," he told the media.

Here's a sensible game plan — plus coaching from an innovator in goal line technology — for late-adopters Blatter and FIFA.

1. Go to the video.

MLB umpires use it to review controversial home runs. NBA officials rely on it to scrutinize three-point shots, goal-tending and buzzer beaters. NFL officials use it to review plays challenged by each team. Perhaps the NHL is the best model for soccer, given their shared concern over not disrupting the flow of the game. It's used for disputed goals, not off-sides calls.

"It's the simplest solution in soccer for goal/no-goal," says Hank Adams, CEO of Sportvision, the industry leader in providing digital extras, such as the virtual first-down marker, for broadcasters and sports leagues. By letting officials review broadcast video only, the same footage that fans see, he says, leagues promote transparency.

2. Rate the refs.

The next step would be adding goal-line technology similar to the Hawkeye system used at Wimbledon. That, used in conjunction with video review, could be used to rate referees on their performance, much the same way Major League Baseball rates its umpires against Sportsvision's digital strike-zone. They get graded on every game and ranked for accuracy. "There was some resistance at first, but now umpires want to know their scores," says Adams. "They use their scores to make the case that they should get playoff assignments." They also use it in training new umpires and preparing to calls games against new pitchers like the Washington Nationals' Stephen Strasburg, to see how his pitches move through the zone.

3. Walk before you run.


There's a new wave of instrumentation coming, with tiny RFID sensors embedded in balls, uniforms, and cleats, to track each athlete's position on the field. Other leagues are experimenting. So should FIFA. "They have an under-17 series," says Adams. "They should try things out there before introducing it at the World Cup level."

Eventually, he says, the sensors will help referees identify off-sides violations, an incredibly hard call to make in real time with lightning fast athletes. A monitoring system could alert officials as soon as a ball is kicked that an offensive player is out of position. After a quick whistle, the game would resume, and any delay could be made up for in overage. It might eliminate the sort brouhaha that erupted when the U.S. team's potentially game-winning goal against Slovenia was erased by a controversial call.


Ultimately, says Adams, the issue for Blatter and the heads of other sports leagues is less about specific technology and more about embracing change. "The more successful these leagues are, the more pressure there is on the people running them not to mess up," he says.

"They see their job is to preserve it, and part of that balancing act is modernizing the game. Football and baseball are always tweaking things. You have to do it in a way that doesn't alienate fans. It usually takes a significant event, like these recent World Cup games, to change the inertia. FIFA must be holding its breath that they don't have similar situations the rest of the tournament."


Read more from Chuck Salter and the rest of the Fast Company crew at