This is a much more obviously mechanical, algorithmic office—INPUT “Request For Copy Of Birth Certificate”; PHOTO ID = YES?; PRINT “Birth Certificate”—than state attorney general, and, truth be told, if we did not have the tradition of it being occupied by an elected human being, a touchscreen kiosk could hold it just as well as anyone. Human judgment isn’t just unnecessary for the office of the county clerk—it’s irrelevant altogether.

Advertisement

This is to say, the county clerk does not get to refuse job duties. Did the MS Office paperclip refuse to Save As? No it did not, except when it was broken, which was always.

But what about my morals???? I have morals!!!!

Congratulations on having morals! I have morals too. So does the office of the Comptroller of Public Accounts for Little Schlichtinburg. The office of the Comptroller of Public Accounts for Little Schlichtinburg’s morals are called “The Law,” and it has to abide by those morals even when the person holding the office doesn’t like it.

Advertisement

That doesn’t make any sense. I am the comptroller! The comptroller and I are one and the same! Consubstantial, as the Catholics say.

Nah.

Listen. In the United States we are lazy about civics and even lazier about language; it’s easier to say Shitbat McGee (that’s you) is the Comptroller of Public Accounts than to say Shitbat McGee holds the office of Comptroller of Public Accounts, but those mean slightly different things, and the latter is more accurate. The office and the officeholder are distinct. You’ll want to understand this, so that you do not make an ass of yourself.

Advertisement

An elected office is just that: an office. No, not a room, but a position. A legal construct. It is not a person. Its substance is made up of the variably complex algorithm of duties and prerogatives and priorities and limits assigned to it by law, and nothing else. This algorithm is like the office’s mind. This mind is all it has. It is living the life of the mind! Its parents must be so proud.

Still, you can see how this could present a problem for, say, the office of the Comptroller of Public Accounts: It has all these duties and prerogatives and priorities and limits, but no goddamn body! This can tend to bog things down. This is why we have elected officials: to grant offices the arms and legs and eyes and voices they need in order to discharge their duties (and to give the terminally ambitious something to campaign for).

Advertisement

Pictured: The office of the Comptroller of Public Accounts.


That’s right, newly elected holder of the office of Comptroller of Public Accounts for Little Schlichtinburg: In your official capacity, you, my friend, are nothing more than the meat suit an inhuman legal entity inhabits. It needs your limbs, so that it can stamp things and use the telephone and spill soy sauce on its keyboard. It does not need your brain for much, beyond your capacity to understand the gig and do it competently. The only moral belief of yours that it requires is a moral belief in obeying the law.

Advertisement

But what if the duties of the office require me to violate my moral beliefs?

Trick question: They do not. Again: You are not the office. You are just the meat suit.

Advertisement

Your religion says using race as a criteria for distributing municipal college tuition funds is evil? That’s fine, because you personally are not being asked to do that. The Comptroller of Public Accounts is doing it, and it needs the use of some limbs and face-holes to get the job done, and hey, here’s this meat suit over here who specifically asked to be given the job. Convenient.

This is a crucial distinction! It should also be a source of solace for conflicted public servants. As a public official, performing the functions of your office, you’re not acting in your capacity as Shitbat McGee, Person With Morals; you’re merely inhabiting the office of the Comptroller of Public Accounts for Little Schlichtinburg. The office, not you, is the one doing the actual legal stuff; the office, not you, is the only one with power to do legal stuff in the first place. The office has duties and powers and such; the officeholder has limbs, permission, and responsibility.

Advertisement

Oh, baloney. If a sheriff refused to jail 17-year-old black kids busted for pot from now on, the dang libturds would call him a hero.

Sure! And if he claimed that the duty of the sheriff’s office to jail people who break drug laws constituted a violation of his right to the free exercise of religion, I would call him a moron. Sheriff is a secular office—as are county clerk and Comptroller of Public Accounts for Little Schlichtinburg and President of the United States—containing no religious capacity whatsoever; it has been a secular office since long before anyone now living was born. It answers to no authority higher than the law, and, at least while acting in official capacity, neither does its officeholder. If that arrangement is incompatible with the tenets of your religious practice, you violated them the moment you accepted the gig.

Advertisement

And what if I just refuse to perform official duties that facilitate things my religion prohibits?

In the legal/procedural sense, you expose yourself to whatever consequences—court orders, impeachment, recall, a fine, jail time, whatever—come along with a refusal to do your job. You might get to talk shit on a cable news show. Depending on which way the wind blows, a cynical politician utterly lacking your deranged, misplaced conviction may run you out onto a campaign stage during the next election cycle as a handy mascot for whichever brand of entitled lunacy he’s pretending to share at the moment. That’s it. Those are the prizes.

Advertisement

Pictured: The reward. Photo credit: AP.


You will not change the law. There will be no Constitutional reckoning over the oppression faced by religious people forced to violate their morals by the duties of their elected offices. No such oppression exists; no one is being forced to violate anything. Again: the office’s highest duty is to the secular law of the land, and has been since long before you won your election; it says so, right in the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which explicitly and unambiguously prohibits government from establishing religion—from imposing religious views on the people, which is what it would be doing if it allowed the religious views of individual officeholders to overrule the lawful duties of their offices.

Advertisement

You’ll lose your court battles; probably, in the next election cycle, your job, too. In the meantime, while you’re stalling, meaninglessly, the official functions of your elected position, you can fill your time by reading. There’s a particular Bible section, from Matthew’s Gospel, that you might find interesting, since we are on the subject of the division between secular and religious concerns:

Then the Pharisees went off and plotted how they might entrap [Jesus] in speech.

They sent their disciples to him, with the Herodians, saying, “Teacher, we know that you are a truthful man and that you teach the way of God in accordance with the truth. And you are not concerned with anyone’s opinion, for you do not regard a person’s status. Tell us, then, what is your opinion: Is it lawful to pay the census tax to Caesar or not?”

Knowing their malice, Jesus said, “Why are you testing me, you hypocrites? Show me the coin that pays the census tax.” Then they handed him the Roman coin.

He said to them, “Whose image is this and whose inscription?”

They replied, “Caesar’s.”

At that he said to them, “Then repay to Caesar what belongs to Caesar and to God what belongs to God.”

When they heard this they were amazed, and leaving him they went away.

Lol owned.

So I can’t choose not to do this stuff, even though I believe it’s wrong?

Sure you can. By resigning. You won’t go to jail for that. Since your concern [ahem] is all about religious freeeeeeeedom—about protecting your own beliefs from government intrusion, and not about using government to impose those beliefs on others—this is the obvious choice, yes? After all, if you’re willing to go to jail on behalf of your freedom of religion, surely you’d also be willing to take a pay cut and a job answering phones at the local church, right? You can be pretty sure you won’t be forced to violate your beliefs there. So: Resign. Problem solved!

Advertisement

We’ll wait. I don’t think we’ll hold our breath.

This sucks! How can I change things so that the Comptroller of Public Accounts for Little Schlichtinburg doesn’t have to do this stuff I don’t like?

Why, by acting in your parallel capacity as a citizen in a republic, of course. Vote for legislative candidates who intend to change the laws. Organize your fellow Little Schlichtinburgers to petition for changes. Persuade people. Run for legislative office, then persuade your fellow legislators to change the laws, and put forth bills to change the laws, and vote for those bills. Become a Supreme Court Justice, however the fuck that happens, and rule that the laws are in conflict with the Constitution.

Advertisement

That sounds like a lotta friggin’ work, man. I’d rather just refuse to perform the duties of my office.

Well, hey. Thanks to all those cuts to education budgets, most people think that’s the same as Rosa Parks refusing to give up her seat, rather than a rejection of some of the only worth-a-shit basic organizing ideas of this nation everybody claims to love so much. You’ll probably get elected Emperor of Patriotland for it. Congratulations.

Advertisement

Top photo via AP


Contact the author at albert.burneko@deadspin.com or on Twitter @albertburneko.