MLB's Plan To Drain Every Last Ounce Of Fun From The Home Run Derby Takes Shape
Kansas City Royals fans were pissed off that Robinson Cano didn't pick Billy Butler for the Home Run Derby, so they booed him. Mercilessly. And each time he failed to hit a home run, compared to the zero times he successfully did, they cheered him. (Burke went ahead and isolated the crowd audio, so you can check that out above.) Whether you think it was classless or hilarious, you can't deny that it was a moment of genuine, communal emotion, and that really annoys Major League Baseball so they're aiming to fix all that.
Because of last night's Canogate—Derbygate? Boogate? Whatever—Bud Selig plans to put the kibosh on this kind of sentiment by possibly forcing a hometown slugger into the Derby wherever the All-Star Game happens to be.
"We'll talk about this [potential rule change]," Selig said during his annual session with the Baseball Writers Association of America. "While I understand [the feelings of fans in] Kansas City ... I felt very badly last night. I felt badly last year for Prince. This was tough."
When another questioner observed the heat — and boos — could even intensify next year with the game scheduled for Citi Field in New York, Selig again lamented Monday's episode.
"It won't be any worse than last night," he said. "You can only boo so loud. ... But let me just say, we'll think about that."
Don't you worry. The Home Run Derby has a glaring problem with fans caring too much about its participants, and the Commish is on it.
Ranking the 2025 NFL Thanksgiving Games by Importance
Tuesday November 25th Best NBA Betting Picks, Predictions
- College Basketball Feast Week Predictions: Top Bets and Maui Invitational Winner
- Panthers vs. 49ers Monday Night Football Week 12 Top Betting Picks, Predictions
- Sunday’s Best NBA Picks & Predictions: November 23rd Top NBA Bets
- Buccaneers vs. Rams Sunday Night Football Week 12 Top Betting Picks, Predictions
- Top 10 NFL Player Props for Week 12: Caleb Williams, Jalen Hurts, Travis Kelce & More
- NBA Picks for Saturday November 22nd Best Basketball Bets
- Week 13 College Football Expert Betting Picks, Predictions

