Reminder: Mel Kiper Stinks At Actually Evaluating NFL Talent
While Big Mel does OK for himself in mock drafts, though not overly OK, we thought it would be prudent to remind you that the last time we looked, Kiper's pre-draft rankings (which are his estimations of how good the players are, not where they will be drafted) stunk pretty hard.
Last year, Tim Burke took a look at draft classes five and 10 years back, and how Kiper's rankings held up. They were not great! In the year since, no one in the '08 class has really shaken out—remember, this is career cumulative value, so that's hard to do in one season—though Aquib Talib had himself a very good season. You can see the original piece in full below.
Latest
Three Eastern Conference Trade Deadline Winners to Watch
Thu Feb 26 2026
Top Three Trade Destinations for Colts QB Anthony Richardson
Thu Feb 26 2026
Why The Darryn Peterson Backlash Has Gone Too Far
Wed Feb 25 2026
Latest Betting
- Thursday Feb. 26th NBA Best Bets: Top Basketball Betting Predictions Today
- Three Best College Basketball Bets For Feb. 25th's Slate
- Three Best NBA Bets for Tuesday Feb 24th's Slate
- NL East Future Betting Picks: Season Win Totals and Division Predictions
- Monday College Basketball Betting Picks for Houston-Kansas and Louisville-UNC
- Olympic Hockey Gold Medal Betting Picks: USA vs. Canada Predictions
- Three MLB Futures Picks to Beat Los Angeles Dodgers in 2026

