Reminder: Mel Kiper Stinks At Actually Evaluating NFL Talent
While Big Mel does OK for himself in mock drafts, though not overly OK, we thought it would be prudent to remind you that the last time we looked, Kiper's pre-draft rankings (which are his estimations of how good the players are, not where they will be drafted) stunk pretty hard.
Last year, Tim Burke took a look at draft classes five and 10 years back, and how Kiper's rankings held up. They were not great! In the year since, no one in the '08 class has really shaken out—remember, this is career cumulative value, so that's hard to do in one season—though Aquib Talib had himself a very good season. You can see the original piece in full below.
Latest
Next Big Stars in WWE: Watch These 2026 Breakout Stars
Mon Dec 08 2025
The AFC Is Wide Open Heading Into Week 15
Mon Dec 08 2025
Kansas City Chiefs Need Offensive Changes This Offseason
Mon Dec 08 2025
Why Kansas City Chiefs Aren't Done Yet Despite 6-6 Record
Sun Dec 07 2025
NBA Best Bets Today: Sunday Dec. 7th Top NBA Picks
Sun Dec 07 2025
Latest Betting
- Top 10 NFL Player Props for Week 14: Best Bets and Expert Picks
- College Football Conference Championship Best Betting Picks, Predictions
- UFC 323 Betting Picks: Best Bets for the Final ESPN Pay-Per-View
- NBA Best Bets Today: Top Betting Predictions for Friday Dec. 5th
- Washington Capitals vs. Anaheim Ducks December 5th Betting Picks, Predictions
- College Basketball Weekend Bets: Gonzaga, Duke, and Michigan State Predictions
- Cowboys vs Lions Thursday Night Football Betting Prediction: Week 14 Bet Picks

