Michael Ajayi's strong outing lifts Butler over Northwestern
Dec 20, 2025; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Butler Bulldogs forward Michael Ajayi (5) goes to the basket against Northwestern Wildcats guard Justin Mullins (20) during the first half at Gainbridge Fieldhouse. Mandatory Credit: Robert Goddin-Imagn Images Michael Ajayi piled up 19 points and a career-high 20 rebounds as Butler held on for a 61-58 victory over Northwestern in the opener of the Indy Classic doubleheader on Saturday in Indianapolis.
Ajayi's ninth double-double of the season, tied for second-most in the nation, enabled the Bulldogs (9-3) to pull through on a day when leading scorer Finley Bizjack finished with a season-low six points.
Jamie Kaiser Jr. contributed 14 points for Butler - two off his career high - before leaving the game with a left ankle injury with 8:51 to go.
Jayden Reid posted 14 points and six assists for Northwestern (7-5), which played without Nick Martinelli (21.9 ppg) due to a concussion suffered in practice. The nation's No. 7 scorer had not missed a game since Jan. 15, 2023, when he was a freshman yet to earn a rotation spot.
Butler flunked its first six possessions before Kaiser cashed a 3-pointer to give the Bulldogs a 3-2 lead shortly before the first media timeout.
Max Green came off the bench to drill a 3-pointer and take a give-and-go from Arrinten Page to the hoop for a layup - giving Northwestern an 11-9 lead midway through the first half - but Butler didn't let the Wildcats lead much longer.
Evan Haywood (11 points) converted a 3-point play, then Kaiser drove for a layup. When Haywood spotted Kaiser for an open 3-pointer, that gave Butler a 20-15 lead with 7:37 left and forced Northwestern to call a timeout.
The Wildcats failed six straight possessions near the end of the half, but K.J. Windham hit a 3-pointer with 36 seconds left to pull Northwestern within 29-23 at the break.
After missing his first six 3-point attempts, Bizjack finally got into the scorebook with a 3-pointer with 18:08 left to help the Bulldogs go on a 7-2 spree to start the second half and take the game's first double-digit lead.
Northwestern gradually reeled in Butler. Reid's drive and hanging layup cut the deficit to 55-53 with 3:43 to play. Page's post-up for a three-point play with 1:54 left pulled the Wildcats within 57-56, but Tre Singleton missed an open 3-pointer on the next possession.
Ajayi answered by posting up for a layup, then Singleton sank a jumper with his toe on the 3-point line. Haywood swished two free throws with 19.8 seconds left to restore Butler's lead to three, then Windham's step-back 3-point attempt to tie banged off the rim.
Butler missed three free throws that would have put the game out of reach, which allowed Reid to hoist a running 35-footer that banged off the glass and the rim at the buzzer.
--Field Level Media
Best NFL Player Props for Week 16: Top Bets and Value Picks
Oklahoma’s 50 Cent Moment Backfires in CFP Loss to Alabama
What Anthony Joshua's Knockout of Jake Paul Means for Boxing
Commanders vs Eagles Week 16 Saturday Betting Pick
- Jake Paul vs. Anthony Joshua Betting Picks: Best Bets for the Boxing Supercard
- Best NBA Picks for Friday December 19th: 76ers vs Knicks, Cavs vs Bulls
- NHL Friday Betting Picks: Hurricanes vs Panthers, Canucks vs Islanders
- College Football Playoff Full First-Round Betting Picks and Predictions
- Best NBA Bets Tonight: Three Picks for Dec. 18th's Slate
- Rams vs Seahawks Thursday Night Football Week 16 Betting Picks
- Wednesday Dec. 17th College Basketball Betting Picks and Predictions

