Blue Jays Challenge Play To Get Their Own Runner Out
Blue Jays manager John Gibbons used MLB's instant replay in an unusual but clever decision in the top of the second of Thursday's game against the Athletics.
The video, which you can watch below, is excruciatingly long, so here's the short version: Toronto had the bases loaded with Anthony Gose at the plate. Gose hit a ground ball to Athletics first baseman Nate Freiman; Freiman tagged Munenori Kawasaki, who was running from first to second, on the butt. Umpire Vic Carapazza ruled that Freiman missed, and Kawasaki was safe. Freiman then threw to home plate, and catcher Stephen Vogt stepped on the base for the forceout on Edwin Encarnacion.
Gibbons came out to challenge the call that Kawasaki was safe, because if the second baseman was called out, there would be no forceout play at home, and the run would score. There you go, John.
After what seemed like ages, the umpires overturned the call and gave the run to the Blue Jays. Athletics manager Bob Melvin ran out to get an explanation and told the umpires the team would play the rest of the game under protest.
Oakland took a lead in the bottom of the second and the Athletics won, 4-1, so Melvin was probably fine with the result.
Why Stephen A. and Skip Bayless Are Reuniting on First Take
NBA Draft Lottery 2026: Odds, Format, and How It All Works
MLB Betting Picks Today: Tuesday May 5th Pitcher Prop Bets
Chandler Simpson Is an Anomaly for Tampa Bay Rays
- Best NBA Bets Today: Game 7 Picks for Cavs vs Raptors, Magic vs Pistons
- Why Cavaliers Should Cover at Home in Game 7 Against Raptors
- Best NBA Playoff Parlays Today: LeBron, Cade Cunningham and More
- UFC Fight Night Perth Betting Picks: Top Bets and Predictions
- Friday May 1st MLB Betting Picks: Top Predictions for Today’s Games
- April 30th NBA Playoffs Best Betting Picks and Predictions
- Kentucky Derby 2026 Picks: Expert Predictions and Top Contenders

