Yankees vs Rays Predictions (09/24/2026): Latest News, Picks & Market Movement

Frank Ammirante
Published: Mon Oct 05 2026
Reviewed By Paul Skidmore
Rays pitcher Drew Rasmussen pitches

The New York Yankees dropped the Divisional Series opener against the Rays in a 1-0 loss. The offense couldn’t get anything going against Drew Rasmussen, who pitched an absolute gem for the Rays, tossing eight innings of scoreless ball with only one hit allowed.

The Tampa Bay Rays will look to take a commanding 2-0 series lead, which would put the Yankees on the ropes. But they’re in trouble because they’re going up against the AL Cy Young favorite, Cam Schlittler. The Rays will need veteran Freddy Peralta to keep up his strong form in this one.

This sets up as another pitcher’s duel. With that in mind, let’s take a look at MLB prediction markets to find value on this game.

Yankees v Rays Picks

Despite being on the road, the Yankees are priced at 53 cents to win this game. This is all because of Cam Schlittler, who has been phenomenal this season, putting up a 1.95 ERA and a 0.92 WHIP in 193.2 innings. Schlittler got off to a terrific start this postseason, tossing 6.1 scoreless innings vs. the Red Sox.

But we can’t count out Freddy Peralta here. He’s been on quite the roll for the Rays. In his last six starts, he’s given up a combined three earned runs in 34 innings, which is good for an otherworldly 0.79 ERA.

To that end, this game can truly go either way, so there’s more value in targeting the total than a side here.

Expert Pick

I don’t like buying into the Yankees as road favorites against a tough Rays team, especially with how well Peralta has been pitching lately. That’s why I’m targeting Under 6.5, which you can get at 49 cents. We just saw these teams play in a low-scoring 1-0 game. There’s a legitimate chance that this one can have a similar result.

Aside from the Schlittler vs. Peralta matchup, each of these teams has fresh bullpens, since they had the day off on Sunday. That bodes well for a low-scoring game.

We saw Schlittler dominate the Rays in eight innings of one-run ball back on July 6th. Don’t be surprised if he has another massive outing here with the Yankees in a must-win game. They can’t afford to go down 2-0 in the series, where they’d be facing elimination heading home.

Yankees vs Rays Latest News

  • The Yankees need to win this game with their ace on the mound. In Game 3, manager Aaron Boone plans to start either Max Fried or Carlos Rodon.
  • Aaron Judge (calf) resumed running, which bodes well for his chances of returning to the lineup if the Yankees can advance to the ALCS.
  • The Rays were completely dominant at home this year, going 55-26.

Yankees vs Rays Market Movement

Back on October 3rd at 9 PM ET, the Yankees were 55% favorites for this game, but their price has fallen to 53 cents. This is likely because the market is reacting to the fact that Freddy Peralta has been excellent lately. In other words, the edge with Cam Schlittler on the mound is not as large as it seems at first glance. To that end, this looks like another pitcher’s duel.

Why Trust Us & Affiliate Disclaimer

Loading …

21+ and present in OH. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Trading on prediction market apps carries risk and may not be suitable for everyone. You could lose the funds and fees you use to enter any transaction. Carefully consider whether participating in prediction markets is appropriate for you, based on your financial situation and experience. All trades and decisions are your own responsibility, and any information provided on this site is for general informational purposes only. Please note that prediction markets fall under the regulatory authority of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).
home › betting › yankees-vs-rays-predictions-(09/24/2026)