Halladay's Perfect Game Was No Surprise To One Nostradamus
One Phillies fan predicted this, and counted down each batter — starting before Halladay even took the mound. Can we retire the concept of jinxes yet?
Are you sick of Halladay perfecto stories yet? Maybe this one will be different, because it predates the actual game. One anonymous ESPN.com user, nicknamed "dtboy1234," started a message board thread called "Roy Halladay Perfect Game Alert." His first post, at 7:16 pm, went up just as Doc took the mound for the bottom of the first. It read, simply, "27 batters to go."
dtboy1234 kept it updated each inning, in relative obscurity. Then, around the sixth inning, other users began to take notice. As dtboy1234 counted down the batters, the thread filled up with people trying to jinx it, claiming he had retroactively edited his posts, and claiming Halladay had thrown to many pitches and should be taken out. (Seriously.)
Shit hit the fan, in the way only an ESPN.com message board can:
THIS THREAD IS EPIC!!! Did he just predicted a perfect game? Yes he did! Unreal...
R u psychic???? What a call. U deserve to be on ESPN or something tom lol. Thats amazing and an amazing game
I never thought the MLB was rigged until now.
So, dtboy1234, congratulations on being a Phillies homer who started these threads at least three times previously. You finally nailed one.
Roy Halladay Perfect Game Alert [ESPN.com] A Random ESPN User Wins The Weekend [The Wiz Wit]
Related
The Minnesota Twins Should've Traded Pablo Lopez Last Year
Why the NBA’s Tanking Problem Isn’t What You Think
Three Quarterbacks With the Most to Prove at the NFL Combine
Are the Pittsburgh Pirates Finally Ready to Contend in 2026?
Two Massive Questions That Will Define the NBA’s Second Half
- Best 2026 American League East Season-Long Future Betting Predictions
- Best College Basketball Bets for Monday: Duke vs Syracuse, Houston vs Iowa State
- NBA All-Star Game Betting Preview: Best Picks for World vs. USA and MVP Odds
- NBA All-Star Saturday Picks: Best Bets for the 3-Point Contest and Shooting Stars
- NBA Three-Point Contest 2026 Best Picks and Prediction Markets for All-Star Saturday
- NBA Picks Tonight: Three Best Bets Before the All-Star Break
- Best NBA Betting Picks for Wednesday Feb. 11th Slate

