NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year Predictions & Picks: Giants Linebacker Dominates the Field

Frank Ammirante
Published: 11/17/2026, 11:23am EST
Reviewed By Paul Skidmore
Giants coach John Harbaugh looks on from the sideline

We’re now firmly in the second half of the NFL season, so it’s the ideal time to take a look at prediction market apps to check out market movement on season awards, such as Defensive Rookie of the Year.

Heading into Week 11, Giants linebacker Arvell Reese is at the top of the board. He was my preseason pick, so it’s nice to see him make an immediate impact for the G-Men. Following Reese is Jets edge rusher David Bailey and Commanders linebacker Sonny Styles.

Since I bought into Reese at a much better price before the season, I would recommend looking elsewhere rather than buying in at a premium.

NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year Picks

Arvell Reese (56 cents) is the clear-cut favorite to win this award. David Bailey (21 cents) is next in line, while Sonny Styles (8 cents) is the only viable longshot. However, there are still 7-8 games left in the season for each team. Do you really want to buy in on Reese at a peak price?

Remember, with prediction markets, we can exit our positions early, so our favorite trade doesn’t have to necessarily win this award for us to secure a profit. That’s why I’m always looking down the board to see if I can pinpoint a longshot who can rise in price over the next couple of weeks.

Expert Pick

I’m buying into Sonny Styles at eight cents to win NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year. The Commanders linebacker looks like the best value at NFL prediction markets. He’s the leader of an improving defense that has performed above expectations in recent games against the 49ers, Eagles, and Giants.

Styles has been a tackling machine, racking up 80 for the season, including 13 in four of his last five games. This includes five tackles for a loss, one sack, one interception, four passes defended, and one forced fumble. When you watch Commanders games, you see the rookie linebacker all over the field.

Sure, Arvell Reese and David Bailey have more gaudy numbers, but Styles is in a position where his price can rise in the coming weeks. After beating the Giants in Week 10, the Commanders remain alive in the NFC East race. If they can go on a winning streak, Styles would likely be a key contributor. That means his price could rise.

Of course, with the NFL, there is always a significant risk of injuries. With so many games left, there is still a risk that one of the favorites misses time, which would open the door for more longshots like Styles. With that in mind, Styles looks like a rock-solid buy at his current price.

Other Contenders for NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year

It’s not surprising to see Arvell Reese as such a heavy favorite for this award. The Giants linebacker has been phenomenal, helping the team exceed expectations and overcome the loss of starting quarterback Jaxson Dart. Reese currently has 79 tackles, eight tackles for a loss, 4.5 sacks, one interception, one forced fumble, and four passes defended.

When I wrote this column in the summer, Reese was my preferred pick, but now his price isn’t worth buying into at 56 cents. That ship has sailed.

The same goes for David Bailey at 21 cents. The Jets edge rusher has an impressive 7.5 sacks this year, but that team is going nowhere, and the defense has really struggled lately. To that end, it’s hard to justify paying such a high price on Bailey at this time.

NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year Market Movement

We’ve seen significant movement in this market. Back in July, Arvell Reese was at around 10% to win this award. But after a dominant first half of the season, Reese is now listed at 56%. Bailey has also increased, going from 14% to 21%. But even with how well they’ve played, I like buying in cheap on Sonny Styles at eight cents. The leader of the Commanders’ defense could see a rise in his price in the coming weeks.

Why Trust Us & Affiliate Disclaimer

Loading …

Trading on prediction market apps carries risk and may not be suitable for everyone. You could lose the funds and fees you use to enter any transaction. Carefully consider whether participating in prediction markets is appropriate for you, based on your financial situation and experience. All trades and decisions are your own responsibility, and any information provided on this site is for general informational purposes only. Please note that prediction markets fall under the regulatory authority of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).
home › betting › nfl-defensive-rookie-of-the-year-predictions-picks