Deadspin HOF Nominee: February 1, 2007
We didn't actually notice what was going on at first; we were at the gym, and we made it back to our desk, there were countless emails: You have to check out what's happening on Simmons' column page. The one-time experiment with Simmons' "conversation" — he hasn't had comments on a column since then, though the rest of Page 2 has caved — turned into an explosion, a storming of the gates the likes of which we hadn't seen.
We never thought the whole uprising thing has anything to do with Simmons himself, and, in fact, we always felt a little bad about some of the comments about the Sports Gal, among other things. It was about a company not really understanding how the Web works, and watching people rush the castle and let the royal court know what they thought. It was immature and ribald and chaotic. But, most important: It was hilarious. It just felt good, you know?
But is it a Hall of Famer? Seventy five percent is the threshold for induction. Vote below: Polls will be open until next Monday morning.
Gawker Media polls require Javascript; if you're viewing this in an RSS reader, click through to view in your Javascript-enabled web browser.
Ranking WWE’s Top 25 Male and Female Superstars of 2026
Everything We Learned in Week 0 of College Football
- UFC Shanghai Betting Odds Line Movements Before Saturday
- UFC Shanghai Best Value Bets: Three Method-of-Victory Props to Target
- UFC Shanghai Underdog of the Week: Denise Gomes Is a Major Value Play
- UFC Shanghai Picks: Three Best Bets for Saturday's Fight Card
- Rockies vs. Braves Picks: Two Best Bets for Friday Night
- Where the Sharp Money is Landing at UFC Shanghai
- College Football Week 0 Picks: Three Best Bets for the Weekend

