Mike Matheny Got Cardinals Job After Telling Bank He Would No Longer Be Making Payments On His Loan
Before trying his hand at managing a baseball team, Mike Matheny tried his hand at being a real estate tycoon. Unfortunately, due to the the economic downturn, several of his projects have gone sour and he was forced to sell his house (pictured above), nestled on 11 acres that included a baseball field, batting cage, private lake and a floating island green within that lake.
Matheny was forced to sell the estate last year amid the business deal gone bad. Like many investors ensnared by the real estate meltdown, he borrowed heavily for a commercial project that would have been less risky in headier times. When demand dried up, Matheny found himself unable to satisfy the debt.
By May 2010, Matheny told the lender that he would no longer make payments. Matheny, who is married with five children, wrote in a letter that he had been making payments "at great expense to myself and my family."
"I certainly hope you can understand that we need to protect our family's interest," he wrote.
The bank sued him a month later.
Obviously the bank did not understand. The Cardinals, however, do understand and don't have a problem with their new manager's decision to just not honor a signed instrument. "'He was very upfront and candid about it from the start of our process,' Cardinals spokesman Ron Watermon said. 'We view this as a personal issue that has absolutely no bearing on his ability to serve as our manager.'"
Matheny is still involved in the litigation and therefore had no comment. He and his wife may still be on the hook for over $4 million when all is said and done, however.
h/t Joseph R. Mike Matheny lost his home in legal fight with bank over business debt [stltoday.com]
Ranking the 10 Biggest Sports Moments From June 2026
World Cup Best Bets Today: Top Picks for France and Mexico
- Canada vs. South Africa Predictions: Best Bets for the World Cup Round of 32
- Wimbledon 2026 Predictions: Best Bets for the Men's Draw
- UFC Baku Picks: Three Bets to Target on Saturday's Main Card
- College Football Championship Odds: Four Value Bets for 2026
- Paul Skenes Headlines Friday June 26th's Best MLB Bets
- Three MLB Bets Worth Targeting on Thursday June 25 Slate
- MLB Picks Today: Backing the Yankees and Phillies-Nationals Over

