The Mystery AL 'Roider: Sheffield, Says You
This image was lost some time after publication. The results are in from our poll asking you who the mystery steroid postseason AL outfielder was, and the winner: Yankees outfielder Gary Sheffield! We supposed we could have guessed that. Despite several commenters' insistence that it couldn't be Sheffield because the story was confirmed by the mystery player's agent — Sheffield currently has no agent, because Sheffield is crazy — he was the runaway winner in the poll. Johnny Damon came in second place, mostly because of the big head, we suspect.
The final standings:
Gary Sheffield, New York Yankees: 32 percent (425 votes) Johnny Damon, Boston Red Sox: 19.8 percent (263 votes) Steve Finley, Los Angeles Angels Of Anaheim: 14.1 percent (187 votes) Gabe Kapler, Boston Red Sox: 8.5 percent (113 votes) Vladimir Guerrero, Los Angeles Angels Of Anaheim: 7.0 percent (93 votes) Scott Podsednik, Chicago White Sox: 5.9 percent (78 votes) Jermaine Dye, Chicago White Sox: 5.3 percent (71 votes) Aaron Rowand, Chicago White Sox: 4.8 percent (64 votes) Hideki Matsui, New York Yankees: 2.7 percent (36 votes)
Thanks for voting. Now, stay tuned. The news will come out eventually ... it always does.
Who's The Mystery 'Roider? [Deadspin]
Related
2026 Home Run Derby Props: Three Best Bets for Monday Night
Ranking Three No. 2 Wide Receivers Better Than Stefon Diggs
Why MLB's Move of the Home Run Derby to Netflix Hurts Fans
Conor McGregor Lets UFC Momentum Slip Away at UFC 329
Why the Trail Blazers’ Ja Morant Gamble Could Pay Off
- UFC 329 predictions: Best bets for Conor McGregor vs. Max Holloway
- Spain vs. Belgium Best Bets: Three Picks for Friday's World Cup Quarterfinal
- MLB Picks Today: Jack Flaherty, Aaron Nola Strikeout Props for Phillies vs. Tigers
- France vs. Morocco Best Bets: Top Picks for World Cup Quarterfinal Clash
- Big 12 Sleeper Picks: Three Teams That Could Win the Conference in 2026
- Scottish Open Predictions: Top Bets, Longshots and First-Round Picks
- MLB Picks for Today: Why the Marlins and Yankees Offer Betting Value

