The Mystery AL 'Roider: Sheffield, Says You
This image was lost some time after publication. The results are in from our poll asking you who the mystery steroid postseason AL outfielder was, and the winner: Yankees outfielder Gary Sheffield! We supposed we could have guessed that. Despite several commenters' insistence that it couldn't be Sheffield because the story was confirmed by the mystery player's agent — Sheffield currently has no agent, because Sheffield is crazy — he was the runaway winner in the poll. Johnny Damon came in second place, mostly because of the big head, we suspect.
The final standings:
Gary Sheffield, New York Yankees: 32 percent (425 votes) Johnny Damon, Boston Red Sox: 19.8 percent (263 votes) Steve Finley, Los Angeles Angels Of Anaheim: 14.1 percent (187 votes) Gabe Kapler, Boston Red Sox: 8.5 percent (113 votes) Vladimir Guerrero, Los Angeles Angels Of Anaheim: 7.0 percent (93 votes) Scott Podsednik, Chicago White Sox: 5.9 percent (78 votes) Jermaine Dye, Chicago White Sox: 5.3 percent (71 votes) Aaron Rowand, Chicago White Sox: 4.8 percent (64 votes) Hideki Matsui, New York Yankees: 2.7 percent (36 votes)
Thanks for voting. Now, stay tuned. The news will come out eventually ... it always does.
Who's The Mystery 'Roider? [Deadspin]
Related
Three NBA Playoff Teams Likely to Be Eliminated Early
UFC Winnipeg Betting Picks: Best Bets for April 18th Card
Why the NBA Must Fix Its Draft System to Stop Tanking
Friday April 17th Expert MLB Betting Picks, Predictions
NFL IQ AI Test: How Accurate Is NFL's New AI Chatbot?
Five Golfers Most Likely to Win Multiple Majors in 2026
- NHL Betting Picks April 16: Top Plays for Final Regular Season Games
- MLB Picks Today: Best Bets for Diamondbacks vs Orioles and Cubs vs Phillies
- NBA Play-In Picks: Best Bets for Warriors vs Clippers and Magic vs 76ers
- NBA Play-In Player Props: Donovan Clingan, LaMelo Ball Headlines Best Picks
- Tuesday April 14th MLB Betting Picks and Expert Predictions
- Sunday NBA Betting Guide: Top Picks for Bucks, Lakers, Timberwolves
- 2027 NCAA Title Odds: Michigan, Duke Lead Early Betting Favorites

