Better Know An Umpire: Jim Reynolds
Welcome to Better Know An Umpire, an effort to educate ourselves on the human elements who have ultimate decision-making power over some 2,500 Major League Baseball games a year. (All cumulative statistics are through the 2011 season, unless otherwise stated.)
Name: Jim Reynolds
Uniform number: 77
Age: 43
Height/weight: 5-foot-11, 185 pounds
First year as MLB umpire: 1999
Total MLB games worked through 2011: 1,642 (home plate: 408)
Previous experience: New York-Penn League, South Atlantic League, California League, Eastern League, Southern League, American Association, International League
Career ejections: 28
No-hitters called: None ( Umpired second base during Roy Halladay's 2010 perfect game)
Over/under record ( 1999-2011): 194-165
Hated in: Northeast Texas, Los Angeles, Denver
Notable alleged blown calls: Twins-Royals, August 12, 2009; Dodgers-Rockies, Sept. 19, 2010; Rangers-Yankees, October 19, 2010 (Game 4, ALCS).
Claim to fame: Was one of 25 replacement umpires hired in 1999, following mass resignations offered by the union.
Scouting report from Major League Umpires' Performance, 2007-2010, by Andy Goldblatt:
His strike zone is clearly pro-pitcher, but run production when he's behind the plate is clearly pro-pitcher. Reynolds has the eighth-highest R/9 for the period under study at the same time he's in the top third in K/BB. ... His career ejection rate is a below-average 1.8 percent, and has dropped to 1.2 percent since 2007.
Scouting report from the New York Post's Ken Davidoff:
RF ump Jim Reynolds is having a rough night. Before the game, he used his salad fork for his steak.
Average K/9 ( 2011): 14.0
Average BB/9 ( 2011): 5.9
Sample PITCHf/x strike zone: May 4, 2012. During last Friday's 13-inning game between Boston and Baltimore, Reynolds' tendency to call outside strikes to right-handed batters was clear.
True fact: Has a degree in journalism from the University of Connecticut. Also, once rescued a distressed bird from the field by scooping it into his mask.
On umpiring:
Every day I have a responsibility to get better even though I'll never be perfect. I will say this, there is nobody in the ballpark when I miss a call who feels worse than I do. I'll never apologize for missing a call because it won't be because I was lazy. But it's not for lack of trying or hustle. I treat every game like the seventh game of the World Series. You learn in a hurry in this job that you can be the lead story on Sportscenter whether you're working the plate in a Yankees-Red Sox game or at third base in a D-backs Pirates game.
Strike 3 call:
To check out other installments of Better Know An Umpire, click here.
Three Teams That Screwed Up 2026 NFL Draft
Red Sox Fire Alex Cora: What It Means for Boston’s Future
What the NBA Draft Should Learn From the 2026 NFL Draft
Best Betting Picks for Saturday’s NBA Playoff Matchups
Four Teams That Are Winning 2026 NFL Draft So Far
- MLB Best Bets Today: Strikeout Props and Total Plays to Target
- NBA Playoffs Betting Picks: Game 3 Predictions & Best Bets
- NBA Playoff Picks: Rockets vs Lakers & Spurs vs Blazers Best Bets
- MLB Betting Picks Today: Two Expert Picks for Tuesday’s Slate
- NBA Playoff Picks: Best Bets for Nuggets vs Timberwolves & Knicks vs Hawks
- Best Value Betting Picks Ahead of 2026 NFL Draft
- UFC Winnipeg Betting Picks: Best Bets for April 18th Card

