Charlotte FC in pursuit of 1st regulation playoff win vs. NYCFC

Field Level Media|published: Mon 27th October, 16:57 2025

Oct 18, 2025; Charlotte, North Carolina, USA; Charlotte FC defender Nathan Byrne (14) and Philadelphia Union defender Olwethu Makhanya (29) fight for the ball in the second half at Bank of America Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Bob Donnan-Imagn Images

Charlotte FC will attempt to earn their first MLS Cup playoff win in regulation when they host a Round 1 series opener against New York City FC on Tuesday night.

Charlotte forced its previous opening-round series in 2024 to three games, but only by winning a penalty tiebreak after a 0-0 draw against Orlando City in Game 2.

Expectations will be higher for the Eastern Conference fourth seed in 2025 now that they've had some experience and added English Premier League veterans Wilfried Zaha and Harry Toffolo to the squad.

"If you think about most of our squad, the base who's been playing, regardless of whether it's playoffs in MLS, they've had experience fighting at the top of the league somewhere," Charlotte defender Nathan Byrne said. "It's very similar all over the world. There's more pressure, there's better atmospheres. It's only what any footballer wants to play in."

But Zaha, who had 10 regular-season goals, will be suspended for the series opener after picking up a red card late in a 2-0 home win over top seed Philadelphia on Oct. 18 to close the regular season. Fellow 10-goal scorer Pep Biel is out for the season with a knee injury.

Meanwhile, fifth-seeded NYCFC should be close to full strength heading into their ninth postseason appearance in 11 total MLS campaigns.

Alonso Martinez posted a second consecutive strong season with 17 goals, while Hannes Wolf added 11. And Argentine summer signing Nicolas Fernandez has scored in two of his last three appearances after a slow start following his summer arrival from Spanish club Elche CF.

New York City ended its regular season with its first consecutive MLS defeats since late March and early April. But those losses came at Supporters' Shield-winning Philadelphia and home to two-time MLS Cup champions Seattle.

Before that, NYCFC won six out of eight across August and September. That included a 2-0 home win over Charlotte, after The Crown won the sides' first fixture by the same score in North Carolina in July.

"The moment is there, what we've been working for all season," first-year NYCFC manager Pascal Jansen said. "We've become way more consistent throughout the season. Apart from the last two games of the regular season, I'm quite pleased with the progression that we've made."

--Field Level Media