Could the Brewers Land Tarik Skubal? The Blockbuster MLB Trade We Want to See

There’s 26 days until a Major League Baseball trade deadline that has potential to fizzle out like a wet firework.

Thanks to the expanded (their adjective)/diluted (our adjective) playoff system, only six teams enter play today more than five games out of a playoff spot.

None of those also-rans — the Kansas City Royals and Los Angeles Angels in the American League and the Cincinnati Reds, New York Mets, San Francisco Giants and Colorado Rockies in the National League — are likely to be dealing impact players at the deadline. Sorry folks, but Bobby Witt Jr., Mike Trout and Juan Soto aren’t going anywhere.

Thus, a baseball nation turns its lonely eyes to the Detroit Tigers and Milwaukee Brewers, who should hook up for a deal that sends two-time American League Cy Young Award winner and impending free agent Tarik Skubal from Detroit to Milwaukee in exchange a top shortstop prospect — Jesus Made or Luis Pena — along with pitcher Logan Henderson and infielder Luke Adams.

This is probably wishful thinking on our part, but let us have some fun for a few paragraphs, OK?

The Tigers are exactly five games out of a wild card spot and are an AL-best 19-12 since bottoming out at 16 games under .500 on May 31. But they’ve only gained two games in the race for the final wild card and climbed into a tie for 13th in the Junior Circuit in that span.

It’s probably time to begin planning for the post-Skubal era by acquiring a top-20 prospect in Made or Pena, who could either move to second or allow the Tigers to shift potential Rookie of the Year Kevin McGonigle to third base full-time.

Henderson, who is almost recovered from a back injury that’s sidelined him since May 26, could take Skubal’s spot in the Detroit rotation (albeit not with the same results) while Adams provides some competition next year (or whenever baseball resumes) for struggling first baseman Spencer Torkelson.

Acquiring Skubal would allow the Brewers — who are on pace to win the NL Central for the fourth straight season and reach the playoffs for the eighth time in the last nine years — to construct one of the most dominant postseason rotations of all-time as they seek the first championship in franchise history.

Skubal, likely NL Cy Young Award winner Jacob Misiorowski and Kyle Harrison have combined to post a 2.38 ERA with a whopping 350 strikeouts in 261 1/3 innings this season. Imagine that 1-2-3 punch opening every playoff series.

The Brewers’ impressive run has been fueled by homegrown talent. But they are loaded with middle infielders — second baseman Brice Turang is a former Gold Glover while shortstop Cooper Pratt, who signed an eight-year deal this spring, played in his 19th big league game Tuesday night — and few teams are better at amateur scouting than Milwaukee.

Now let’s drop that firecracker into a giant bucket of water, shall we?

The Tigers will be reluctant to sell — not only because they went all-in by adding Framber Valdez to the rotation for Skubal’s final season but because the AL Central is where borderline miraculous playoff runs are born.

Detroit was 10 games out of a playoff spot on Aug. 10, 2024 but went 31-13 the rest of the way to earn a wild card berth. Last year, the Cleveland Guardians went 24-8 after Aug. 25 to erase the Tigers’ 12 1/2-game AL Central lead and drop them into a wild card spot. Why can’t lightning strike a third time, especially in an underwhelming AL?

The Brewers, meanwhile, have been the masters of the under-the-radar in-season moves since 2017. Nobody thought Jordan Lyles and Drew Pomeranz were big additions in 2019, when they accounted for 2.9 in post-deadline WAR. Nor did anybody expect Andrew Vaughn to post an .869 OPS after being acquired on June 13, 2025.

Even with a World Series within their grasp — and the next CBA shaping up to be very small market-friendly, even if it costs everyone the 2027 season — the Brewers aren’t likely to deviate from the cautious homegrown formula that’s made them a powerhouse. Good for them, but probably bad for a potential dud of a trade deadline.